• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

This view of service management...

On the origin and the descent of managing services. We put meat on the bones.

  • Kanban eLearning
  • Services
    • Kanban Software Solutions
    • Consulting & Coaching
    • Training & Seminars
  • Posts
  • Events
    • Events – Agenda View
    • Events – Calendar View
    • International Service Management Calendar
  • Publications
    • Our Publications
    • Notable Publications
    • Quotes
  • Subscribe

Technology and Agility

7 June 2018 by Robert Falkowitz Leave a Comment

A recent visit to the ancient site of Epidauros brought to mind some thoughts about how technology can work adversely to agility.

The site of Epidauros is perhaps one of the most famous of Hellenic antiquity. Its Askleipion is inscribed in the list of world heritage sites.

Theater at Epidauros
Fig. 1: The theater at Epidauros

While the theater itself is in fairly good shape, due primarily to the efforts of the Roman conquerors and modern archæologists, most of the other buildings are in a state of considerable ruin, due to a com­bi­na­tion of weather, earth­quakes and vandalism.

This is a big issue for the tourism industry, so important to the e­co­nomy. People like to see ancient, grandiose constructions, like the Egyptian pyramids of Gizeh, the Mayan temples of Tikal or the sacred architecture at Angkor Wat. In Athens, what percentage of visitors go to see the Parthenon, with its erect columns, and what percentage visit the nearby ancient agora? Thus, the incentive to restore ruins, erect fallen columns and pose lintels on them.

How to do this, given the poor state of preservation of most building elements, combined with the desire for authenticity, with­out cheating the visitor by mixing the ancient with the modern?1 At Epidauros, a solution is being ap­plied that makes use of high technology.

Fig. 2: A modern part is created in which an ancient part will be inserted.
Fig. 3: An ancient part is fitted into the space created in the modern part

The ancient pieces, as is, cannot be restored to their original positions. They are simply too damaged, too incomplete. So the pieces are measured using high technology. Next, a modern piece is created with a negative space in which the ancient piece is to be fitted. The resulting pieces are structurally sound. At the same time, it is easy to see what is ancient and what is modern. The modern parts are of brilliant white marble, whereas the patina of age betrays the ancient parts. Finally, the hybrid pieces can be reassembled to approximate the original building.

More restored pieces of columns
Fig. 4: More examples of restored column components
Restored columns at Epidauros
Fig. 5: Partial restoration of columns, metopes, architrave, etc.

The issue with using this extremely sophisticated tech­no­logy is that it is anything but agile. The method is slow, certainly expensive and based on a set of hypotheses that might be reasonable, but serve to re­pro­duce our modern con­cep­tion of what ancient Hel­lenic arch­i­tec­ture looked like. If new in­for­ma­tion were to become available, demonstrating that the re­con­struction is inaccurate, how likely is it that the pieces would be dismantled and rebuilt differently?

When we use sophisticated tools to help us reach our goals, we might recall Horace’s ode:

I have built a monument more lasting than bronze,
higher than the Pyramids’ regal structures,
that no consuming rain, nor wild north wind
can destroy…
2

We might take pride in our technical achievements, our com­plex tools to automate and to manage, but isn’t the purpose of the structure more important than the edifice itself? Should we not take into consideration the likelihood that the tools themselves only serve to ac­cu­rate­ly reproduce our unstated biases? A house built of straw might not resist the big bad wolf, but at least it has the merit of being easily adapted, dismounted, moved or rebuilt, should our requirements change.

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International LicenseThe article Technology and Agility by Robert S. Falkowitz, including all its contents, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Notes:

1See Umberto Eco, Faith in Fakes, especially the essay “Travels in Hyperreality”.

2Book III. Translation from https://collation.folger.edu/2016/03/more-lasting-than-bronze/

Summary
Technology and Agility
Article Name
Technology and Agility
Description
A small lesson from Epidauros on the relationship of technology and agility
Author
Robert S. Falkowitz
Publisher Name
Concentric Circle Consulting
Publisher Logo
Concentric Circle Consulting

Filed Under: Agility Tagged With: technology, tools

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Phone
  • Twitter
  • xing
  • YouTube

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Kanban eLearning

Kanban training online

Recent Posts

  • The Three Indicators
  • Visualization of Configurations
  • How to increase visualization maturity

Tag Cloud

change management Cost of Delay Incident Management change control priority manifesto kanban incident value resource liquidity knowledge work problem lean management flow urgency process metrics knowledge management process definition waste kanban board automation service request risk value stream Service Management manifesto for software development lean bias agility incident management tools agile impact rigidity service manager flow efficiency service management tools ITIL cause adaptive case management context switching
  • Kanban eLearning
  • Services
  • Posts
  • Events
  • Publications
  • Subscribe
  • Rights & Duties
  • Personal Data

© 2014–2021 Concentric Circle Consulting · All Rights Reserved.
Concentric Circle Consulting Address
Log in

This site uses cookies . You accept those cookies when you continue to use this site. Cookie policyAllow cookiesNo 3rd party non-functional cookiesCookie policy
You can revoke your consent any time using the Revoke consent button.Change cookie settings